SCOUT TROUT ELITE
  • SCOUT TROUT ELITE
  • FB DATABASE
    • TOP 2025 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 OL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 DL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2026 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 RB RECRUITS
        • 2026 TOP RB RECRUIT ADRIAN SYMALLA
      • TOP 2026 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 OL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 DL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2024 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 D-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 O-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 LINEBACKERS
      • TOP 2024 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2023 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 QUARTERBACK RECRUITS
        • TOP 2023 DUAL-THREAT QB'S
        • TOP 2023 PRO-STYLE QB'S
      • TOP 2023 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 TE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 O-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 D-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 DB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 SPECIALIST RECRUITS
    • QB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Quarterback Recruits
        • TOP 2022 DUAL-THREAT QB'S
        • 2022 TOP PRO STYLE QB's
      • 2021 Quarterbacks
    • ATH RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Athlete Recruits
      • 2021 Athlete Recruits
    • D-LINE RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Defensive Line Recruits
        • TOP 2022 DE RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 DT RECRUITS
      • 2021 Defensive Linemen
    • OL RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • TOP 2023 LINEMEN RECRUITS
      • 2022 Offensive Linemen
        • TOP 2022 OT RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 OG RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 CENTERS
      • 2021 Offensive Linemen
    • LB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Linebacker Recruits
      • 2021 Linebackers
    • WR RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • TOP 2022 WIDE RECEIVER RECRUITS
      • 2022 Tight End Recruits
      • 2021 Wide Receivers
      • TOP 2021 TE RECRUITS
    • TOP RB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Running Backs
      • 2021 Running Backs
    • TOP DB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Defensive Backs
        • TOP 2022 SAFETY RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 CB RECRUITS
      • 2021 Defensive Backs
    • Special Teams
      • 2022 Specialist Recruits
      • 2021 Specialist Recruits
    • 2022 TOP FB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 TOP FB RECRUIT RANKINGS
    • TOP 2023 JUCO FB RECRUITS
      • TOP JUCO RECRUITS
    • TOP FOOTBALL RECRUIT RANKINGS
    • 2020 Signings
    • 2019 CFB Recruits
    • Evaluation Profiles - Class of 2019
  • News & Reports
  • SIGNEES
    • CFB PLAYERS
    • 2024 FB OFFERS
    • 2022 Football Signees
    • 2021 FB COMMITS
  • NFL DRAFT
    • 2023 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECT RANKINGS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT RB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT WR PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT TE PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT OL PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT DL PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT LB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT DB PROSPECTS
    • NFL DRAFT GRADES
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECT RANKINGS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT RB PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT WR PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT TE PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT OL PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT IDL PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT EDGE PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT LB PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT DB PROSPECTS
    • HOWELL NFL DRAFT 2025
  • Sign Up
  • Partners
    • MICHIGAN ELITE FOOTBALL RECRUITING
  • About
    • Recruiting Pipeline Program
    • Eligibility 101
    • Football Training
    • FAQ
    • Contact
  • SCOUT TROUT ELITE
  • FB DATABASE
    • TOP 2025 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 OL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 DL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2026 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 RB RECRUITS
        • 2026 TOP RB RECRUIT ADRIAN SYMALLA
      • TOP 2026 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 OL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 DL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2024 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 D-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 O-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 LINEBACKERS
      • TOP 2024 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2023 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 QUARTERBACK RECRUITS
        • TOP 2023 DUAL-THREAT QB'S
        • TOP 2023 PRO-STYLE QB'S
      • TOP 2023 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 TE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 O-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 D-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 DB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 SPECIALIST RECRUITS
    • QB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Quarterback Recruits
        • TOP 2022 DUAL-THREAT QB'S
        • 2022 TOP PRO STYLE QB's
      • 2021 Quarterbacks
    • ATH RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Athlete Recruits
      • 2021 Athlete Recruits
    • D-LINE RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Defensive Line Recruits
        • TOP 2022 DE RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 DT RECRUITS
      • 2021 Defensive Linemen
    • OL RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • TOP 2023 LINEMEN RECRUITS
      • 2022 Offensive Linemen
        • TOP 2022 OT RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 OG RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 CENTERS
      • 2021 Offensive Linemen
    • LB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Linebacker Recruits
      • 2021 Linebackers
    • WR RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • TOP 2022 WIDE RECEIVER RECRUITS
      • 2022 Tight End Recruits
      • 2021 Wide Receivers
      • TOP 2021 TE RECRUITS
    • TOP RB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Running Backs
      • 2021 Running Backs
    • TOP DB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Defensive Backs
        • TOP 2022 SAFETY RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 CB RECRUITS
      • 2021 Defensive Backs
    • Special Teams
      • 2022 Specialist Recruits
      • 2021 Specialist Recruits
    • 2022 TOP FB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 TOP FB RECRUIT RANKINGS
    • TOP 2023 JUCO FB RECRUITS
      • TOP JUCO RECRUITS
    • TOP FOOTBALL RECRUIT RANKINGS
    • 2020 Signings
    • 2019 CFB Recruits
    • Evaluation Profiles - Class of 2019
  • News & Reports
  • SIGNEES
    • CFB PLAYERS
    • 2024 FB OFFERS
    • 2022 Football Signees
    • 2021 FB COMMITS
  • NFL DRAFT
    • 2023 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECT RANKINGS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT RB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT WR PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT TE PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT OL PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT DL PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT LB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT DB PROSPECTS
    • NFL DRAFT GRADES
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECT RANKINGS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT RB PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT WR PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT TE PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT OL PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT IDL PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT EDGE PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT LB PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT DB PROSPECTS
    • HOWELL NFL DRAFT 2025
  • Sign Up
  • Partners
    • MICHIGAN ELITE FOOTBALL RECRUITING
  • About
    • Recruiting Pipeline Program
    • Eligibility 101
    • Football Training
    • FAQ
    • Contact
Search

FOOTBALL RECRUITING NEWS

Scout Trout Elite football recruiting news is brought you by former All-American football player Merf Trout. 

TOP FOOTBALL RECRUITS

Scout Trout Elite top football recruits scouting reports & much more can be found below at the world's most successful college football recruiting company!

Notes from President sperling- effects of cognitive dissonance on sports recruiting

6/1/2018

Comments

 
College Football Schedule, College Football rankings, college football gameday, cognitive dissonance , ncaa football, college football playoffs, espn college football, espn college sports, top college fb recruits
Recently, while posting about an all-state running back I felt had been overlooked on many ranking sites, I found myself in argument with an online stranger who refused acknowledge any source that did not have his favorite running back from a well-known football school at the top of its rankings. While not a bad football player, had decent at best statistics and when my boyfriend and I finally fast-forwarded through all the flashy intros of his highlight videos, there was nothing that exceptional about them aside from the cinematography, of course. At first, we were both confused and a bit frustrated that people take these videos that have more shots of the athlete posing, warming up, and how shiny his helmet is than any actual plays. Now, I like a little flash just as much as anybody in 2018, but I hardly see how these quick, intermittent runs in 4K accompanied by catchy music makes this recruit's actual talent worthy of 5 stars.
For those who never took a college psych class or have simply never heard this term, Cognitive Dissonance is defined as, “the mental conflict that occurs when beliefs or assumptions are contradicted by new information” (britannica). In order to ease the tension created by this contradiction of facts, our brain will do backflips to maintain consistency among our beliefs, attitudes, and actions. Cognitive dissonance can be seen in literally any kind of argument, and the world of sports journalism is far from an exception, as sports fans and broadcasters are almost always strongly convicted. The Browns are more likely to win a Super Bowl in the next 5 years than a Patriots fan is likely to listen to an opposing argument and conclude that maybe Tom Brady is perhaps a tad overrated. More likely they will do whatever they can to refute, discredit, or over explain any fact that contradicts their firmly held belief that Brady is the greatest quarterback of all time.  When discussing athletes, sports fans, broadcasters and radio hosts will often resort to titles and statistics to reaffirm the superiority of one athlete over another, even though last week that same “expert” went on a rant about how statistics or titles are not definitive because he believed that athlete just wasn’t that good. That’s how people debate and discuss things, right? Dig so deeply into your opinion and never concede on anything regardless of the facts presented before you. Yes, that’s fine, whatever. But while cognitive dissonance is a natural part of the way humans argue with one another, it also obscures our ability to judge and think critically, especially in the information age.
With the be-all, end-all star-based rating system monopolized by 247 and Rivals, cognitive dissonance can have a deep influence on how we look at college football recruits. When we unquestionably accept 5-star ratings based on 30 alleged offers as ultimate indicators of athleticism and talent, our brains are highly motivated to confirm this fact in order to avoid any inconsistency. Likewise, when watching nearly identical film of a low or unrated prospect, we are more prone to giving a harsh critique that will justify their low media presence or lack of FBS offers. Even more likely, we will disregard the recruit entirely because we are invested in these abstruse online rankings as an accepted fact, which we will be naturally inclined to preserve by rejecting contrary information. The truth is that there are thousands of overlooked high school ball players out there with impressive film, record-breaking stats, and NFL-level combine numbers that simply haven’t had the same media exposure that their peers featured on 247 and Rivals have. The difference often has little to do with the talent of the athletes, and more to do with who was in the right place at the right time. Many of the highly ranked big time recruits go to schools known for having a highly competitive program in a highly competitive area. Here is where cognitive dissonance plays a huge part in the recruiting process itself, as a coach will overlook below average stats and combine numbers in order to stay consistent with the widely held conviction that these schools and areas produce the top talent in the country. What’s more, with the number of FBS offers being a prerequisite for giving out an offer to recruit, coaches and recruiting staff are holding the decisions of other programs as unquestionably valid.  In fact, In the 6 months I’ve spent working in college football, I’ve learned that “well, who’s offered him?” is one of the first things a coach will ask when inquiring about a recruit. When the answer to this question is not a list of top D1 programs, it is not uncommon for a program to assume a recruit’s lack of offers is due to an off-the-field issue or even lead them to reconsider the recruit’s talent entirely. And just like that, a ball player’s value as a student-athlete is now entirely reliant on what the internet has to say about him, as college football fans across the internet are also heavily reliant what they find on 247 and Rivals. Working within this system of stars and alleged offers where Hudl views are more valuable than leading your state in receptions, those who recruit student-athletes no longer have to exercise critical analysis to differentiate one prospect from another. For this reason, one of the biggest motivations behind making the S.T.E.P. Ratings was re-introducing critical elements of what makes a top recruit. So, whether you’re a student-athlete, a coach or scout, or just a fan, be aware of cognitive dissonance and how you form your opinions. ​

Click to Read about what it takes to be a 5 star recruit by clicking below! Great job Maddy! 

College Football Schedule, College Football rankings, college football gameday, cognitive dissonance , ncaa football, college football playoffs, espn college football, espn college sports, top college fb recruits
Comments

    NEWS

    CFB NEWS

    Breaking football scouting & recruiting news

    Categories

    All
    2018-allamerican-bowl
    Athletes
    CFB Recruiting 101
    Class-of-2018-reports
    Class-of-2019-reports
    Class-of-2020-reports
    Class-of-2021-reports
    Defensive-backs
    Defensive Linemen
    Linebackers
    Offensive Linemen
    Quarterbacks
    Running-backs
    Sports-psychology
    Step-ratings-rankings
    Tight-ends
    Wide-receivers

    Archives

    December 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016

    RSS Feed

Scout 

Recruit

Offers

© COPYRIGHT 2015. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • SCOUT TROUT ELITE
  • FB DATABASE
    • TOP 2025 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 OL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 DL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2025 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2026 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 RB RECRUITS
        • 2026 TOP RB RECRUIT ADRIAN SYMALLA
      • TOP 2026 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 OL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 DL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2026 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2024 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 QB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 D-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 O-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 LINEBACKERS
      • TOP 2024 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2024 DB RECRUITS
    • TOP 2023 FOOTBALL RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 QUARTERBACK RECRUITS
        • TOP 2023 DUAL-THREAT QB'S
        • TOP 2023 PRO-STYLE QB'S
      • TOP 2023 RB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 WR RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 ATH RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 TE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 O-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 D-LINE RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 LB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 DB RECRUITS
      • TOP 2023 SPECIALIST RECRUITS
    • QB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Quarterback Recruits
        • TOP 2022 DUAL-THREAT QB'S
        • 2022 TOP PRO STYLE QB's
      • 2021 Quarterbacks
    • ATH RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Athlete Recruits
      • 2021 Athlete Recruits
    • D-LINE RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Defensive Line Recruits
        • TOP 2022 DE RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 DT RECRUITS
      • 2021 Defensive Linemen
    • OL RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • TOP 2023 LINEMEN RECRUITS
      • 2022 Offensive Linemen
        • TOP 2022 OT RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 OG RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 CENTERS
      • 2021 Offensive Linemen
    • LB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Linebacker Recruits
      • 2021 Linebackers
    • WR RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • TOP 2022 WIDE RECEIVER RECRUITS
      • 2022 Tight End Recruits
      • 2021 Wide Receivers
      • TOP 2021 TE RECRUITS
    • TOP RB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Running Backs
      • 2021 Running Backs
    • TOP DB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 Defensive Backs
        • TOP 2022 SAFETY RECRUITS
        • TOP 2022 CB RECRUITS
      • 2021 Defensive Backs
    • Special Teams
      • 2022 Specialist Recruits
      • 2021 Specialist Recruits
    • 2022 TOP FB RECRUIT RANKINGS
      • 2022 TOP FB RECRUIT RANKINGS
    • TOP 2023 JUCO FB RECRUITS
      • TOP JUCO RECRUITS
    • TOP FOOTBALL RECRUIT RANKINGS
    • 2020 Signings
    • 2019 CFB Recruits
    • Evaluation Profiles - Class of 2019
  • News & Reports
  • SIGNEES
    • CFB PLAYERS
    • 2024 FB OFFERS
    • 2022 Football Signees
    • 2021 FB COMMITS
  • NFL DRAFT
    • 2023 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECT RANKINGS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT RB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT WR PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT TE PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT OL PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT DL PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT LB PROSPECTS
    • 2022 NFL DRAFT DB PROSPECTS
    • NFL DRAFT GRADES
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT QB PROSPECT RANKINGS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT RB PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT WR PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT TE PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT OL PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT IDL PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT EDGE PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT LB PROSPECTS
    • 2021 NFL DRAFT DB PROSPECTS
    • HOWELL NFL DRAFT 2025
  • Sign Up
  • Partners
    • MICHIGAN ELITE FOOTBALL RECRUITING
  • About
    • Recruiting Pipeline Program
    • Eligibility 101
    • Football Training
    • FAQ
    • Contact